Octopus Mislabeling Suit to Continue

A California federal court has denied Vigo Importing Co.’s motion to dismiss a lawsuit alleging the company mislabels its products as containing octopus when they are actually composed of jumbo squid. Fonseca v. Vigo Importing Co., No. 16-2055 (N.D. Cal., order entered October 26, 2016). Vigo Importing sought to dismiss the claim on jurisdictional grounds, arguing that based on its sales figures, the amount in controversy could not possibly meet the $5 million threshold required by the Class Action Fairness Act to allow a federal court to consider the case. The court disagreed, noting that the sales price was only part of the calculation; the potential damages determination requires information on the cost of the products as well as the value of the product if composed of jumbo squid. Details on the complaint appear in Issue 602 of this Update.

Issue 621