Wisconsin Federal Court Dismisses Butter-Grading Lawsuit
A federal court has granted summary judgment to Wisconsin in an Ohio dairy’s lawsuit alleging a Wisconsin law requiring butter to be graded by the U. S. Department of Agriculture or a state-licensed grader violated the commerce, due process and equal protection clauses of the U.S. Constitution. Minerva Dairy, Inc. v. Brancel, No. 17-0299 (W.D. Wis., entered February 5, 2018). In its complaint, the dairy alleged that small companies are unable to afford USDA grading or the creation of separate packaging solely for Wisconsin sales, effectively blocking them from the state’s market.
Finding that Wisconsin has a legitimate government interest in requiring grading labels on butter packages to assure consumers of product quality, the court held that the law does not violate the U.S. Constitution’s equal protection or due process clauses. The court reasoned that the law does not give Wisconsin butter makers “a categorical ‘competitive advantage over their counterparts outside the state,’” thus creating no disparate impact on or treatment of out-of-state manufacturers.