A multidistrict litigation (MDL) court in New York has granted in part the motion to dismiss filed in a putative class action alleging that Frito-Lay North America and PepsiCo., its parent, mislead consumers by labeling various Tostitos®, SunChips® and Fritos Bean Dip® products as “all natural” when they contain genetically modified organisms (GMOs). In re Frito-Lay N. Am., Inc. All Natural Litig., MDL No. 2413 (E.D.N.Y., order entered August 29, 2013). The court dismissed PepsiCo, Inc. from the litigation without prejudice, finding that the complaint failed to allege sufficient facts to support its liability. Among other matters, the court refused to dismiss the suit on the basis of (i) the primary jurisdiction doctrine (noting that the issues do not require specialized knowledge to resolve and that “the FDA [Food and Drug Administration] is unlikely to respond in a timely manner to any referral from this Court”), (ii) preemption (finding that FDA’s…
Tag Archives GMO
A federal court in California has issued an order granting the motion for preliminary approval of a class settlement in five lawsuits alleging that Naked Juice Co. misrepresented its beverages as “All Natural” and “Non-GMO.” Pappas v. Naked Juice Co. of Glendora, Inc., No. 11 8276 (C.D. Cal., order entered August 7, 2013). According to the court, the proposed settlement was reached after the defendant’s motion to dismiss was granted in part, extensive and contentious discovery was undertaken, and four mediation sessions occurred under the guidance of an experienced retired judge. Under the terms of the settlement, the company will pay $9 million into a settlement fund that will be used to make cash payments to class members and pay the costs of notice and settlement administration, attorney’s fees—not to exceed $3.1 million—and expenses, and incentive awards $2,500 each for four of the five named plaintiffs. Class members with purchase receipts…
A Florida resident has filed a putative statewide class action against Gruma Corp., alleging that the company falsely advertises its Mission® Restaurant Style Tortilla chip products as “all natural” when they contain genetically modified organisms (GMOs). Griffith v. Gruma Corp., No. 13-80791 (S.D. Fla., filed August 12, 2013). Alleging violations of the Florida Deceptive and Unfair Trade Practices Act and contending that her claims “mirror the labeling, packaging, and advertising requirements mandated by federal regulations and laws,” the plaintiff claims that the products are misbranded and the labels are false and misleading because GMOs are not natural and she understood that product representation to mean that the chips contained no GMO ingredients. Alleging damages in excess of $5 million, the plaintiff seeks injunctive relief, restitution, disgorgement, actual damages, attorney’s fees, costs, and interest.
An August 7, 2013, Slate article by Genetic Literacy Project Executive Director Jon Entine has criticized a recent magazine story allegedly linking eosinophilic disorder—“a multisystemic condition in which white blood cells overproduce in response to allergens”—to genetically modified (GM) corn, calling out Elle writer Caitlin Shetterly for stoking “conspiratorial fears that the government is covering up evidence that GMO foods can damage the public health.” According to Entine, the article in question “was particularly appalling” insofar as it failed to produce any evidence or tests to confirm the “unusual diagnosis” that GMO foods caused Shetterly’s autoimmune disorder. Instead, Entine argues, Shetterly relied on a “journalistic trick… to frame a settled issue in the scientific community as a mystery or a controversy.” “There has not been one study that links the genetically engineered corn or any approved genetically modified food on the market to allergies,” University of California, Davis, plant geneticist…
According to news sources, French President François Hollande has said that the country will maintain its prohibition on growing genetically modified (GM) corn sold by Monsanto, despite a Council of State court ruling reversing the moratorium on the ground that it had little legal basis. The ban on MON810 corn has been in effect in France since February 2008 and was extended in 2012. The July 29, 2013, court ruling was the second to overturn the ban—the first ruling, in 2011, was also ignored by former President Nicolas Sarkozy. While Monsanto was not a party, it said in response to the verdict, “The decision by the Conseil d’État is welcome support for a science- and evidence-based approach to GM crop policy in France and the EU. The decision confirms that farmers throughout the EU should have the right to use seeds that European authorities have approved for use throughout the…
A federal magistrate has recommended that General Mills’ motion to dismiss a putative consumer fraud class action be denied without prejudice and that, under the primary jurisdiction doctrine, the suit be stayed “pending action by the FDA [Food and Drug Administration] with respect to the referral made by Judge Rogers in Cox v. Gruma. Van Atta v. General Mills, Inc., No. 12-2815 (D. Colo., recommendation entered July 18, 2013). At issue is the company’s claim that its granola bars are “100% Natural” when they allegedly contain genetically modified organisms (GMOs). Finding that the food-labeling issue falls within FDA’s regulatory authority and that the agency “has not issued a rule which requires products containing GMOs to be labeled as such, nor has the FDA issued a rule regarding whether products labeled ‘natural’ may contain GMOs,” the magistrate found invocation of the primary jurisdiction doctrine appropriate. In this regard, the magistrate stated,…
Japan has reportedly announced that it will resume purchasing U.S. white wheat, ending a two-month suspension that was implemented after genetically engineered crops were found on an Oregon farm in April 2013. According to a news source, Japan imports nearly five million tons of wheat per year—60 percent of which comes from the United States—but does not allow genetically modified wheat. Purchases of western white wheat reportedly resumed on August 1, while purchases of soft white wheat for livestock feed will resume August 7. See japantoday.com, August 2, 2013.
A federal court in California has dismissed some of the consumer fraud claims filed against Chobani, Inc. in putative class litigation alleging that the company mislabels its yogurts as containing “evaporated cane juice,” misleads consumers by stating that its products do not contain added sugar and falsely states that its products are “all natural” because they contain artificial ingredients, flavorings, coloring, and chemical preservatives. Kane v. Chobani, Inc., No. 12-2425 (N.D. Cal., order entered July 12, 2013). The court granted with leave to amend (i) the motion to dismiss as to the evaporated cane juice claims to the extent they are based on products not purchased by the plaintiffs; and (ii) the motion to dismiss the plaintiffs’ Unfair Competition Law (UCL), False Advertising Law (FAL) and Consumers Legal Remedies Act (CLRA) claims based on the “no sugar added” and “all natural” representations, finding that the plaintiffs did not sufficiently allege…
Naked Juice Co. has agreed to settle putative class claims that it falsely advertised some of its juice and smoothie products as “all natural” and not genetically modified (GMO); while denying the allegations, the company will establish a $9 million settlement fund. Pappas v. Naked Juice Co. of Glendora, Inc., No. 11-8276 (C.D. Cal., motion for preliminary approval filed July 2, 2013). Members of the putative nationwide class will each be eligible under the proposed agreement to recover a maximum of $45 dollars. The agreement will also require Naked Juice to establish a product verification program, hire or assign a quality control manager to oversee the independent testing process for the company’s product line, establish a database to allow the electronic tracking and verification of product ingredients, and modify future labeling, advertising and marketing to cease using “All Natural” and related statements.
According to a news source, the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) has become involved in the search for the person or persons responsible for the destruction of genetically modified (GM) sugar beet crops in southern Oregon. The purported “economic sabotage” occurred in different fields during two nights in June 2013 and resulted in the loss of some 6,500 plants. Oregonians for Food and Shelter has reportedly offered $10,000 for information leading to the identification, arrest and conviction of the perpetrators. The state Department of Agriculture secretary said that to her knowledge “this is the first time someone has deliberately taken the cowardly step of uprooting high value plants growing in our state. Regardless of how one feels about biotechnology, there is no justification for committing these crimes.” See Ag Professional, June 24, 2013.
