The Animal Legal Defense Fund (ALDF) has filed a putative class action against a large-scale, California-based egg producer alleging that it falsely represents that the eggs are laid by hens “raised in wide open spaces in Sonoma Valley.” ALDF v. Judy’s Family Farm Organic Eggs, No. ___ (Cal. Super. Ct., filed October 1, 2012). According to ALDF, the hens are actually “crammed in covered sheds with no outdoor access.” The animal rights group alleges violations of California’s Unfair Competition Law, False Advertising Law and Consumers Legal Remedies Act. The organization cites Michael Pollan’s The Omnivore’s Dilemma, which discussed the defendant and its parent company, also named in the suit, as follows: “Who could begrudge a farmer named Judy $3.49 for a dozen organic eggs she presumably has to get up at dawn each morning to gather? Just how big and sophisticated an operation Petaluma Eggs really is I was never able to…
Tag Archives New York
A federal court in New York has dismissed with prejudice claims that Mario Batali’s Del Posto restaurant allegedly retained portions of workers’ tips in violation of federal and state labor laws after approving an agreement requiring the defendants to pay $1.15 million into a settlement fund and provide workers with training and paid vacation time and sick leave. Amastal v. Pasta Resources, Inc., No. 10-07748 (S.D.N.Y., order entered September 24, 2012). Additional information about the lawsuit can be found in Issue 368 of this Update. The 31 plaintiffs in this lawsuit had opted out of a similar class action involving captains, servers, waiters, bussers, runners, backwaiters, bartenders, and barbacks at Del Posto and seven other restaurants; the class action apparently concluded with a $5.25 million settlement deal preliminarily approved in May. Details about the class action appear in Issues 361 and 430 of this Update. The deal also apparently releases claims…
A federal court in New York has denied a motion to dismiss a consumer fraud action against the company that makes Four Loko®, a beverage allegedly containing high alcoholic and caffeine content and sold without disclosing “possible negative health effects.” Yourth v. Phusion Projects, LLC, No. 11-1261 (N.D.N.Y., decided September 27, 2012). The defendant contended that the court lacked subject matter jurisdiction on the ground of mootness “because defendant has offered ‘to fully refund any amounts that Plaintiff paid for Four Loko as well as any fees and costs he incurred.’” Noting that the circuit courts have split over whether a defendant can moot a putative class action by offering to satisfy the plaintiff’s demand before a motion for class certification is filed, the court concluded that “unless plaintiff has unduly delayed in moving for certification, defendant’s offer of full relief does not moot the action.” According to the court,…
The New York City Department of Health and Mental Hygiene (DOHMH) has announced that more than 30 public and private hospitals have joined its voluntary Healthy Hospital Food Initiative, a new program seeking to make healthier food choices available in health care settings. Billed as part of the department’s ongoing effort to curb obesity, the new initiative requires participating hospitals to implement the NYC Food Standards established in 2008 by Mayor Michael Bloomberg in four areas: “cafeterias, beverage vending machines, food vending machines and patient meals.” According to DOHMH, these standards are based on U.S. Department of Agriculture and Institute of Medicine nutritional guidelines and “use progressive strategies to make healthy foods easily available.” Under the new initiative, hospital cafeterias must use a variety of techniques “to make the healthy choice the easy choice” by increasing the availability of fresh fruits, vegetables and whole grains; limiting the promotion of high calorie…
New York State Senator Gustavo Rivera (D-Bronx) has introduced a bill (S7849-2011) that would require fast-food restaurants offering incentive items, such as toys, with children’s meals to meet certain nutritional guidelines. The standards, designed to limit the amount of fat, sugar, calories, and sodium per meal, would be established by the state health commissioner. “Incentive items” under the proposal, which has been committed to the Committee on Rules, would also include games, trading cards, admission tickets, “or other consumer product, whether physical or digital, with particular appeal to children.” Such items would also include “any coupon, voucher, ticket, token, code or password which is provided directly by the restaurant and is redeemable for or grants digital or other access to any toy, game, trading card, admission ticket, or other consumer product” appealing to children. The measure defines restaurant to include coffee shops, cafeterias, luncheonettes, sandwich stands, diners, short-order cafes, fast-food…
A New York resident has filed a putative class action against The Dannon Co., alleging that because the company adds “filler materials, such as water, corn starch, and Milk Protein Concentrate” to products that it sells as yogurt, the products contain “banned additives” and, as a matter of federal law, are not yogurt, are misbranded and “cannot legally be sold in the United States.” Conroy v. The Dannon Co., Inc., No. 12-6901 (S.D.N.Y., filed September 11, 2012). A number of allegations in the complaint, including a history of yogurt-making, are carbon copies of a complaint filed in a California federal court in August 2012 against Cabot Creamery Cooperative, alleging that its Greek-style yogurt cannot be sold in the United States for similar reasons. Filed by the same law firm, that case is discussed elsewhere in this Update. Seeking to certify a nationwide class and New York subclass of product purchasers, the…
The New York City Board of Health has adopted Mayor Michael Bloomberg’s recommendation to establish a maximum serving size of 16 ounces for sugar-sweetened, non-alcoholic drinks sold at local food establishments. Board members reportedly voted 8-0 with one abstention, one absence and one vacancy to amend Article 81 of the Health Code to place a size restriction on beverages containing more than 25 calories per eight ounces and all self-service cups offered by food vendors, with exemptions for products that are more than 50 percent milk or 100 percent fruit or vegetable juice. Effective March 13, 2013, the new regulations will apply to restaurants, mobile food carts, delis, theater and stadium concessions, and any other food-service business regulated by the city’s Department of Health and Mental Hygiene, which will impose fines of $200 per violation. “Today’s vote is a historic and important step in fighting New York City’s epidemics of…
“In an era of political polarization, Michael Bloomberg has the rare ability to come up with policies that enrage everyone,” opines New Yorker staff writer James Surowiecki in this August 13, 2012, article analyzing the mayor’s plan to prohibit all New York City food vendors from selling sodas in sizes larger than 16 ounces. Surowiecki argues that despite bipartisan disdain for the proposal, Bloomberg’s scheme “makes clever use of what economists call ‘default bias,’” the tendency for consumers to choose certain options not because they reflect actual needs or desires but because they are presented as the default selection within the context of other choices. As Surowiecki recounts, researchers have allegedly shown that people calibrate their consumption habits by outside cues “like the size of a package or a cup” as opposed to feelings of satiety. “And since the nineteen-seventies the portion sizes offered by food companies and restaurants have…
A federal magistrate judge in New York has determined that the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) must begin proceedings to withdraw its approval of the use of certain antibiotics in livestock for non-therapeutic purposes on the agency’s timeline, thus denying FDA’s request for a stay while the matter is pending on appeal before the Second Circuit. NRDC v. FDA, No. 11-3562 (S.D.N.Y., decided August 8, 2012). In June, the court determined that FDA arbitrarily denied petitions filed by advocacy organizations in 1999 and 2005 requesting the initiation of these proceedings. More information about the case appears in Issue 442 of this Update. The magistrate first ruled on the Natural Resource Defense Council’s (NRDC’s) motion to strike a document from the record; it was an Animal Health Institute statement “expressing general support for the FDA’s plans to reduce the non-therapeutic use of medically-important antibiotics in animal feed through a voluntary guidance…
A New York resident has filed a putative class action against Diamond Pet Foods and Amazon.com, seeking medical monitoring for pets that consumed recalled Salmonella-tainted pet food. Cohen v. Schell & Kampeter, Inc., d/b/a Diamond Pet Foods, No. 12-3299 (E.D.N.Y., filed July 2, 2012). Plaintiff Steven Cohen alleges that he fed his dogs Taste of the Wild® brand pet food, purchased from Amazon.com, and that they became ill, vomiting frequently, “which caused damage to Plaintiff’s property.” Seeking to certify a nationwide class and statewide subclass of consumers, the plaintiff alleges breach of implied and express warranty, strict products liability, violations of state consumer fraud laws, negligence, and unjust enrichment. In addition to medical monitoring, the plaintiff seeks actual damages or restitution, attorney’s fees, costs, and interest. A Canadian non-profit representing the interests of foie gras producers, a New York-based foie gras producer and a company that operates restaurants in California have…
